
Not all 4G networks are created equal. AT&T, Verizon and Sprint use terms like 4G, 4G LTE and HSPA+ to market smartphones to customers.
However, these buzzwords offer little in the way of explanation as to how reliable the three major U.S. networks perform when it comes to high-speed data downloads.
That's why we decided to test out 4G LTE phones of all three major U.S. carriers in Los Angeles, Santa Monica, Hermosa Beach, and on everyone in LA's second home, the highway.
Armed with a trio of smartphones that consumers are likely to buy today, we examined the coverage, speed, and price using an iPhone on AT&T's network and a pair of Samsung Galaxy S4 phones on Verizon and Sprint's network.
Three will enter. one will win.
What is 4G LTE exactly?
4G LTE is a high-speed wireless standard built into newer smartphones that is 10 times faster than 3G connections.
That's a significant speed bump amounting to a theoretical 300 MB/s. But LTE, or "long-term evolution," is just a bridge to the 1GB/s that was originally outlined for 4G.
LTE-Advanced is supposed to offer that in the future.
Until then, carriers are marketing to (and confusing) consumers with terms like "super fast 4G LTE" and "true 4G" - as opposed to fake counterfeit 4G LTE.

Who says they have the best 4G network coverage?
Verizon claims to have "America's largest 4G LTE network" that covers 95 percent of the U.S. population. It boasts that "Verizon is America's most reliable network. Period." That's three periods in a row, so you know the company is super serious.

AT&T uses similar marketing claims, though far less punctuation, touting "the nation's largest 4G network" and "the nation's fastest and most reliable 4G LTE network."
Sprint doesn't participate in any of the silly one-upmanship. Instead it by promising to continue to roll out "more reliable coverage, stronger signals and increased data speeds."
Verizon and AT&T can't both be right. Right?

Who actually has the best 4G network coverage?
Testing out all three smartphones with the best speed test apps available for iOS and Android, we found that Verizon had a slightly more consistent signal save for a few areas that received little to no data.
Verizon was more reliable than AT&T and Sprint in the city, especially indoors, and only faltered in the outskirts. That's still a serious problem for data-deprived people who live in the suburbs.
AT&T would sputter indoors during a few tests, but its data speeds would jump right back up at other times, offering strong but overall inconsistent coverage. Its main weakness was indoor venues in the skyscraper-filled downtown area.
Sprint had more in common with Verizon than AT&T. Coverage was okay in the city, but less reliable further from the center of Los Angeles and on highways.

It's all about the coverage map
Verizon had the more consistent network city-by-city, but there's another piece of information you should always check before buying into a new 4G LTE network: the coverage map.
The Verizon, AT&T and Sprint 4G LTE coverage maps from CellReception pinpoint the location of each network's tower locations. In a way, they back up exactly what our speed tests found.

Verizon did pitiful in Hermosa Beach and Manhattan Beach, for example. That's because the carrier has fewer cell towers in this stretch of the California coastline. Sure enough, our tests reflected that.
The No. 1 thing you can do before signing up for a new network is to check the 4G LTE coverage maps before making the switch.

The best 4G network speed
While it was a region-dependent split decision between Verizon and AT&T when it came to reliable coverage, AT&T stayed true to its claim of offering the "nation's fastest 4G LTE network."
AT&T 4G LTE speeds topped 33 Mb/s in some tests and averaged 22.3 Mb/s. When testing the Verizon 4G LTE speeds, we were lucky to get 5 or 10 Mb/s.
AT&T and Verizon upload speed were surprisingly strong for both networks at 10 Mb/s.
Sprint download speeds were meager in comparison to both of its rival carriers, averaging between 1 and 5 Mb/s overall in our tests, sometimes giving us a network error to boot. Surprisingly, its upload speeds, when there wasn't an error message, were stronger than a lot of its download speeds, consistently at 3 and 4 Mb/s.

4G LTE price plan comparison
Here's where Sprint beats both AT&T and Verizon quite handily. Sprint charges just $30 a month for its 4G LTE unlimited data per line, or $20 a month for 1GB.
Verizon and AT&T don't provide unlimited plans anymore, except to long-time AT&T iPhone owners who still cling to their grandfathered-in data plans for dear life.
But the same $20 that gets you 1GB of data on Sprint would leave AT&T customers with less than a third of that - 300MB - for an entire month. AT&T's 3GB option is $30, and the 5GB tier is $50 a month.
Verizon lumps its 4G LTE data into the "unlimited talk and text" price, making it difficult for a direct comparison. The end result is $90 a month for a lousy 1GB of data, which is $20 more every month than what Sprint offers its customers.
Sprint's 4G LTE network hasn't rolled out everywhere, but if it's in your area, saving $240 a year isn't such a bad deal.

Final 4G LTE speed tips
AT&T was the fastest of the three carriers in our 4G LTE data tests, but that's only half of the story. Consistent coverage throughout the U.S. is the biggest hurdle every network needs to address.
Therefore, rule No. 1 of buying a new smartphone with a different carrier than you're used to is check the AT&T, Verizon, and Sprint coverage maps with your zip code plugged in.
You don't want to get stuck in a two-year contract with a carrier that has a lack of cell towers in your neck of the woods.
Rule No. 2 is to talk to friends. Everyone seems to incessantly complain or, rarely, biasly rave about their cell phone reception - this is usually due to a lack of knowledge when there are problems that exist. But poll enough people and you may be surprised.
As carriers prep 4G LTE-Advanced and new smartphone supporting the upgraded speed, we could see theoretical speeds of 1GB/s. Until that rolls out, however, we'll keep testing the 4G LTE networks to see which is the best in all sorts of environments.

No comments:
Post a Comment